Joan W. Blos - A Gathering of Days: A New England Girl's Journal, 1830-32 A Novel

Pros: Very descriptive, makes you feel like you are involved in the story

Cons: None

Review: A Gathering of Days is one of my favorites of the Newbery winners. It is sometimes a difficult story to read because of the depth of emotion conveyed throughout the book. Death, unfortunately, was an always-looming threat in the 1830's, due to disease...

Pros: Personal, short read

Cons: Weak plot, unengaging content, annoying tone

The Bottom Line: Although this book might be a quick, cute read for young girls, it's sorely lacking in almost every other aspect. I would recommend practically any other "diary book" before it.

Review: A Gathering of Days – ah, does that bring back sweet childhood memories? Perhaps, but not for me! I know someone is gasping in shock; you mean Greatpilgrim, the ultimate reviewer of classics, is criticizing a Newberry Medal winner? The sky is ...