Mystic River
 
3.7
Based on 68 user reviews
78% recommend this product
5 stars
16
4 stars
29
3 stars
12
2 stars
7
1 star
4
Share your thoughts
Write A Review

Consumer Reviews

Showing 1 - 20 of 68 Reviews

Sort by:
608

Absolutely NOT the sequel to ?Mystic Pizza?

bytruckturner Dec 4, 2011
19 Helpfuls 20 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Performances, characters, script, direction
Cons Denouement, Laura Linney, one unnecessary subplot
Recommended it? Yes

Three kids from an Irish neighbourhood in Boston are accosted by a stern plainclothes detective for general adolescent idiocy (writing their initials in wet cement), and one of them is ushered away by the detective. It turns out, he wasn’t a detective but one of a pair of paedophiles who keep... Read full review »

516

Not for the faint-hearted - or kids

bybusby777 Oct 22, 2010
24 Helpfuls 25 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros looks at the dark side without flinching, makes you think
Cons clues too subtle, violent, solution the the murder comes out of left field
Recommended it? Yes

Mystic River (2003) is a tale of violence, yet it does have a story.  And it does not depend upon special effects.  The stars are there for their acting ability, not for their star power.  And they look like real people, not like movie stars.  It is based on the novel by Dennis... Read full review »

119

Grim story line, but very well made movie indeed!

bybenezah Jan 20, 2010
14 Helpfuls 15 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Everything about this movie.
Cons Nothing.
Recommended it? Yes

I have seen this four or five times over the past seventeen years, and keep forgetting about it. You may think by that statement think this movie is not that good. I would personally think other wise. Some may even suggest it is a re-work of sleepers, but not me. I am glad I forget about it as... Read full review »

41

Uncompromising, grueling. A cinematic powerhouse.

byswmckewon Jun 8, 2009
15 Helpfuls 16 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Beautifully directed. A showy performance from Sean Penn that actually works.
Cons Plot strays into the incredulous right at the end.
Recommended it? Yes

Infused with near-biblical power, Clint Eastwood's "Mystic River" is a straight hard drink of masculine theory, a journey into the world's dark, vengeful crevices, where the strong eat the weak, yet are not spared by God, and pay dearly for the feast. Beginning in the streets of Boston during the... Read full review »

301

The Mystery of Character

bymgscmwa Jan 7, 2007
16 Helpfuls 17 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Wonderful Performances
Cons Don't expect a happy ending in this one!
Recommended it? Yes

I do not think I have enjoyed a film so much when there were absolutely no redeeming characters. There were truly no sympathetic or redeeming characters in Mystic River. It is a film of despair, disconnected characters, and lost youth.

Mystic River starts in the most appropriate way it... Read full review »

George_Chabot
2596

The Last Time I Saw Dave: Mystic River

byGeorge_Chabot Jan 9, 2005
91 Helpfuls 92 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Sean Penn, Kevin Bacon, Tim Robbins
Cons Screenplay non-sequiturs, women not given much to do
Recommended it? Yes

"We bury our sins here. We wash them clean" Jimmy Markum

Clint Eastwood's Mystic River tells the tale of three scarred men. It poses the question, "can we ever escape our pasts?" A brief prologue establishes that one of the three had had his youth rudely snatched away by a pair of... Read full review »

43

Clint Eastwood's Mystic River

bydarkofnight Dec 12, 2004
37 Helpfuls 38 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Excellent performances, the first half is really good.
Cons Everything goes to Hell in the second half, horrible music, poor cinematography.
Recommended it? No

****WARNING: This review contains spoilers throughout.****

Mystic River is a sad thing indeed: a film that begins well and then slowly spirals down until it becomes a mess of melodramatic theatrics, plodding scenes, and embarrassing moments of extreme coincidence and convenience.
... Read full review »

25

Why I don't like this wordly acclaimed movie

byadicos Nov 2, 2004
13 Helpfuls 14 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros very good script, very good actors
Cons The message left is just not right
Recommended it? No

wanted to watch this movie for quite some time, mostly because it was directed by Clint Eastwood and 3 relatively good actors are in the cast. I am talking about Sean Penn, Tim Robbins and Kevin Bacon. They are not great actors, but they are there…And I shouldn't forget Laurence Fishburne, as... Read full review »

5

Subtle twists and underplayed hints kept me riveted!

bybalstrom Sep 21, 2004
6 Helpfuls 7 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Gripping, great acting, maximum suspense, nice pace.
Cons A few loose ends. Horrible overacting by wife of prime suspect.
Recommended it? Yes

I didn't know anything about this movie when I rented it on a whim. I was amazed that I hadn't heard more about it. Sean Penn turned in an Oscar performance, and I've never cared much for him, but he was absolutely compelling, complex, and gave a beautifully understated performance.

The... Read full review »

2072

Mystic River: wolf justice

bytelynor Sep 2, 2004
86 Helpfuls 87 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Well done story about something we don't want to think about happening.
Cons Unrelently grim, this isn't something for light viewing.
Recommended it? Yes

I was of two minds when it came to watching this film. The subject matter -- the murder of a young woman -- and the resulting damage that it creates among three men, was something that I knew would disturb me. On the other hand, I had heard and seen quite a few reviews that were praising the film... Read full review »

598

When your best friend is really not your best friend?Mystic River

bykld718 Aug 21, 2004
91 Helpfuls 92 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Penn, Bacon, and Robbins
Cons Linney, predictable
Recommended it? Yes

I was not really interested in Mystic River when it first hit the theaters. To tell you the truth, I didn't actually hear a lot about the movie until it was nominated at a few of the awards shows. So I surprised myself by picking this movie up one day in Blockbuster. I don't know why I did because... Read full review »

200

A Promising Drama Sold Out for a Twist

byFurie Aug 6, 2004
36 Helpfuls 37 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Sean Penn, some good character development, Boston
Cons A twist ending that muddles instead of clarifying, drags
Recommended it? Yes

What I get most out of Clint Eastwood's Mystic River is a sense of my dad's Boston. When I mentioned that I'd seen the film, my dad said, "How about those Savage brothers? I knew a lot of guys like that." The Savage brothers are a couple of vicious hoods in the film, guys who'd kill you so you... Read full review »

wsmunch
103

Outstanding Cast Performance

bywsmunch Aug 2, 2004
25 Helpfuls 26 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros The cast, the cast, the cast
Cons Simple story, sometimes predictable, not much for action
Recommended it? Yes

I love good acting. You can take a simple, mediocre story with a couple of twists and a may-or-may-not-surprise-you ending and make it very enjoyable; with the right cast. I know I have seen movies directed by Clint Eastwood before, but this was the first time that I was paying attention, and I was... Read full review »

1

For Insomniacs Only!

byclemicus Aug 1, 2004
14 Helpfuls 15 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros The film does have an ending.
Cons Its overall pretension to being a major noir film.
Recommended it? No

I recently rented and viewed Mystic River partly because of a friend's recommendation and partly to see what all the hullabaloo over this film was about. Well, i must say it was a bore of a film from start to finish. It never really took off and how it was even nominated for the number of awards it... Read full review »

531

On Par to Enjoying a Night Watching a Fish in a Fishbowl ? Mystic River

bylynus Jul 27, 2004
43 Helpfuls 44 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Tim Robbins.
Cons Too moody. Boring in parts. Predictable ending.
Recommended it? No

I'm going to lead off with my dissatisfaction with the DVD of Mystic River. Not since the early hay-days of DVD's has a movie been released at full price with so few special features. Besides the movie, the DVD provides nothing! The reason for this lackluster DVD is to cause people to buy first... Read full review »

Bryan_Carey
3651

"We Bury our Sins Here, Dave. We Wash Them Clean"

byBryan_Carey Jul 27, 2004
121 Helpfuls 122 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros The performances; The story
Cons Moves slowly at times; Some mysteries are never touched
Recommended it? Yes

Based on a novel by Dennis Lehane, Mystic River is a suspenseful crime/drama/mystery film with an all- star cast. This movie was nominated for several Oscars at the 2004 ceremonies and it walked away with two prizes: Best Actor and Best Supporting Actor.

Movie Facts:

Rating: R... Read full review »

28

An Open Letter to Mystic River

bysaucylittleone Jul 20, 2004
24 Helpfuls 25 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Excellent acting, gripping story (at least at first)
Cons Doesn't live up to its promises
Recommended it? Yes

"Mystic River," I wanted so long to love you, and love you well. You see, I'm afraid I'm going to have to ask for a divorce. You just didn't live up to my hopes and expectations; when I wanted love, when I wanted fairness, when I wanted trust, you deceived and manipulated me, leaving the foul... Read full review »

dragonfire88
1728

Sean Penn and Tim Robbins Turn in Award Winning Performances in Mystic River

bydragonfire88 Jul 19, 2004
114 Helpfuls 115 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Cast, acting, directing, and story
Cons Turned predictable near the end.
Recommended it? Yes

Clint Eastwood has been an actor for years. Later in his career, he started to direct as well. He has directed several movies, and won the Oscar for best director for his work on Unforgiven. In the fall of 2003, his newest movie, Mystic River was released.

Dave, Jimmy, and Sean were... Read full review »

481

Mystic River

byBounty628 Jul 13, 2004
24 Helpfuls 25 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Kevin Bacon, however, was the shining star in this film
Cons none
Recommended it? Yes

With all of the hype that surrounded Sean Penn's performance in this film, I felt I had an almost civic duty to check out this film. Going into "Mystic River" I must say I had high expectations that this film would not disappoint. I am happy to say that it passed in flying colors.

... Read full review »

297

Mystic River -- Sinkin' like Charles Stuart

byDukeSunflow Jul 13, 2004
32 Helpfuls 33 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Nice sense of place.
Cons Overblown acting, undercooked script, ending from left field.
Recommended it? No

Mystic River was the first book by Dennis Lehane that I couldn't finish. As I plowed through it, I found I just didn't really care where the story wound up.

Still, the book receive tons of praise from critics everywhere, and when the movie based on the book did the same, I thought, well,... Read full review »

Prices are provided by the merchants. We assume no responsibility for accuracy of price information provided by merchants. Please alert us to any pricing discrepancies and we will alert the merchant. Sales taxes are estimated at the zip code level. Shipping costs are estimates. Please check store for exact shipping costs. To learn more about why certain stores are listed on the site, click here

Product specifications are obtained from third parties, and while we make every effort to assure the accuracy of product information, we do not assume any liability for inaccuracies. Store ratings and product reviews are written and submitted by online shoppers to assist you as you shop. They do not reflect our opinions. We take no responsibility for the content of ratings and reviews submitted by users.

Copyright © 2000-2013 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved

http://img.shoppingshadow.com/jfe/JavaFrontEnd-fe130.rtb22.p4-13356
http://img.shoppingshadow.com/jfe/JavaFrontEnd-fe130.rtb22.p4-13356