Based on 21 user reviews
29% recommend this product
5 stars
4 stars
3 stars
2 stars
1 star

Consumer Reviews

Showing 1 - 20 of 21 Reviews

Sort by:

Works great when new

bysmogman67 Nov 18, 2007
6 Helpfuls 7 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Excellent timer on and off feature, also brew strength and temp.
Cons Prone to brakedown, multiple failures of the product in a very short time.
Recommended it? No

My old coffee maker died just after getting married, so we bought the ISX23. Cost a lot, but worth it. Then it started leaking after six months. I opened it up and fixed it. Then the timer stopped working. Main reason for purchasing it. Now after 18 months, the heat element is out. I can't find... Read full review »



byabva Aug 29, 2007
8 Helpfuls 9 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Looks nice, clean updated look.
Recommended it? No

I bought this coffee maker and in less then a year the delay brew quit working. I called Mr. Coffee and complained and they sent me a brand new one, which I thought was great. Now I had the coffee maker leaking all over counter top, in drawer and cabinet, which I am sure will cause water damage to... Read full review »


WORST Coffeemaker I had!

byshopper44 Mar 10, 2007
6 Helpfuls 7 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros good looking
Cons slow, leaks, noisy
Recommended it? No

It says 12 cup but 8 is the maximum you can safely do. Even then, sometimes leaks. POOR DESIGN! all the others has similar complaints, so I guess we should be entitled to a refund or replace!!
DO NOT BUY!!!!! Read full review »


Mr. Coffee/Mr. Sloppy

byjodster22 Feb 15, 2007
5 Helpfuls 6 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Attractive
Cons It belongs in the garbage dump!
Recommended it? No

This is the absolute worst kitchen appliance I have ever owned! I have owned coffee pots that have lasted 10 years. This one has over flowed over 6 times or more in a year and made the worst mess all down my new cabinets. I really think that Sunbeam Products should have a recall on this product and... Read full review »


What you read is true!!

byjpg77373 Jan 26, 2007
6 Helpfuls 7 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros None really, a pretty cool looking clock on the front?
Cons None, besides mopping and drinking coffee off of the countertop.
Recommended it? No

Mr. Moppy. This space waster is an awful waste of money. Slow at everything except belching coffee and grounds all over the countertop. I had to shampoo the carpet at the lakehouse because of this POS. If you really want one, call me I'll give you mine. Read full review »


Works great

bymarine011956 Jan 21, 2007
10 Helpfuls 11 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros The adjustable hot plate and the dual display for the clock.
Cons Not fast brewing, but neither was my old one.
Recommended it? Yes

I've only had this coffee maker a few weeks now, but so far I haven't had any of the problems of waking up to a leaking coffee maker, although I can see how you could if not careful. There is a small hole in the back of the coffee maker and if the water filter gets clogged up and the water can't go... Read full review »



bywordhopper502 Jan 8, 2007
11 Helpfuls 12 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros digital display, pleasant audible signals, chrome accents, no water leaks, adjustable...
Cons takes about twelve minutes to brew a full pot, water reservoir hard to clean
Recommended it? Yes

I like this coffee maker. I'm really surprised by some of the negative reviews. It's a great value from Costco. Bought this Mr Coffee ISX23 about two months ago. It's been leak-free unlike most coffee makers I've owned. I'm guessing the water filter may cause a water leak if the owners don't change... Read full review »


Love it!

bycyndiedwards Dec 12, 2006
6 Helpfuls 7 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Stylish and funky
Cons none
Recommended it? Yes

I haven't had a problem with this coffee maker and I've been using it for 8 months. No spills, just great coffee every morning. I'm very surprised about the negative reviews. I think it's great. Read full review »


Piece of junk!

bydavoswoman Sep 7, 2006
2 Helpfuls 3 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Looks good.
Cons Everything else!
Recommended it? No

We've had this for about 8 months. It didn't take long for the clock to get fogged up and almost unusable. It is slow and leaky. I always thought Mr. Coffee was the best. Boy was I wrong. I cleaned it last night with vinegar mixture and now it won't turn on at all and the clock is totally gone... Read full review »


last Mr coffee

bygbirk Aug 2, 2006
2 Helpfuls 3 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros nice looking
Cons p.o.s. I'll be selling mine for 5$ at garage sale...
Recommended it? No

coffee spilled over counters a number of time. After one year of service, I'm sick of sitting and watching it to make sure i don't end up with a pot of coffee all over the counter and non in the pot. stay clear Read full review »


Pretty face--sloppy brewer

bydoninaz May 19, 2006
3 Helpfuls 4 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Eye appeal, lots of controls for brewing and timing.
Cons Prone to leakage of brew
Recommended it? No

The Mr. Coffee ISX23 is one of the best looking coffee makers out there. It looks really nice on the counter, it has a bright clock, plenty of controls for timing, brew strength and plate temperature. However, the basket design will allow the brew to miss the carafe and leak onto the warming plate... Read full review »


Mr. Coffee owes us an apology

byncfmichael Mar 25, 2006
5 Helpfuls 6 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Cons so terrible it overshadows any pros
Cons Leak leak leak leak leak leak
Recommended it? No

Like some of the other reviewers, we went with this coffee maker as an upgrade. Some nice features, the automatic start and nice looks appealed to us. So we paid a little more than we normally would for what we thought would be our best coffee maker ever. What a disappointment! From the very... Read full review »


Don't judge a book by its cover...

byjunebugz Mar 23, 2006
18 Helpfuls 19 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Looks
Cons Everything else ... especially the leaking
Recommended it? No

Probably close to a year and a half ago we decided to get a new coffeemaker. We could have probably gotten anything on the shelf and it would certainly have been better than one of the first issues of those "free" coffeemakers you get if you join the Gevalia coffee service. So we went looking... Read full review »


Piece of Junk!!

bypjbmet Feb 12, 2006
2 Helpfuls 3 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Looks good. Looks good.
Cons Everything else.
Recommended it? No

All of the reviews that I have read on this appliance (unfortunately AFTER I bought it) are consistent. Within a short period of time, this thing begins to leak all over the counter. Also, the little gizmo designed to let you get a cup prior to the entire pot brewing doesn't work well, and you end... Read full review »


Do Not Buy This!

bydsnell66 Jan 19, 2006
10 Helpfuls 11 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros appearance
Cons leaks coffee and water all over the counter pathetic design of pause and serve valve
Recommended it? No

I used a little four cup Mr Coffee for years and decided to update. When I first used it I thought the coffee tasted old. I tried the strong setting and it was no better. During the first week that I had it, it overflowed all over the counter because the pause and serve valve didn't get pushed open... Read full review »


makes good coffee

bycurleygirl63 Jan 16, 2006
8 Helpfuls 9 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros brews good coffee timer plate temp. warmer cord storage nice pot, no leaky spout
Cons takes too long to brew a pot
Recommended it? Yes

I bought this because my thermal version (same model) didn't keep my coffee warm.
This model keeps it as warm as I like it, with its neat warmer control. The clock is a cool glowing green LCD that resembles a regular dial clock with a second hand, and easy to read, and the timer is very easy... Read full review »


What Were They Thinking?

bymaggielover Dec 10, 2005
7 Helpfuls 8 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros Nice design on the outside. When it worked, it brewed a good pot of coffee.
Cons Poor design on the inside and outside. Too many parts to clean. Leaks, leaks, leaks!
Recommended it? No

We have used Mr. Coffee products in the past without incident, so when up-to-date features/designs came out on their new coffeemakers, we decided to pay the extra money and buy the ISX23 model. We are heavy coffee drinkers and usually brew two 12-cup pots a day - sometimes more. After a few days of... Read full review »



bythepone Sep 14, 2005
13 Helpfuls 14 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros looks pretty i guess
Recommended it? No

this is by far the worst appliance, maybe machine in general, made on earth. we owned it for less than 6 months, took care of it properly (regular cleanings, etc.) - it started to leak all over the counter - the coffee would spurt straight out the drip mechanism and run down the pot. so we called... Read full review »


Coffee everywhere but the pot!

bykocos Sep 8, 2005
7 Helpfuls 8 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros good coffee
Cons coffee everywhere
Recommended it? No

I've had this coffee maker about four months. At first I thought the problem was me not putting the carafe back correctly when making the coffee but that is not the problem. Again today, after carefully setting the carafe where it belongs and turning it on, the coffee maker decided it was on pause... Read full review »


slow slow slow

byiastate11 Aug 26, 2005
4 Helpfuls 5 Helpfuls Was this review helpful?
Pros stylish, pot does not drip. temp adjustment for warmer is neat. timer easy to set.
Cons bright clock. slow brewing,
Recommended it? Yes

looks good, stylish, Very slow brewing. Have had no problems in coffee spilling at all. My previous Mr coffee maker always dripped on the counter. Read full review »

Prices are provided by the merchants. We assume no responsibility for accuracy of price information provided by merchants. Please alert us to any pricing discrepancies and we will alert the merchant. Sales taxes are estimated at the zip code level. Shipping costs are estimates. Please check store for exact shipping costs. To learn more about why certain stores are listed on the site, click here

Product specifications are obtained from third parties, and while we make every effort to assure the accuracy of product information, we do not assume any liability for inaccuracies. Store ratings and product reviews are written and submitted by online shoppers to assist you as you shop. They do not reflect our opinions. We take no responsibility for the content of ratings and reviews submitted by users.

Copyright © 2000-2015 eBay Inc. All Rights Reserved